This post is adapted from Pete Grieg's book 'God On Mute: Engaging the Silence of Unanswered Prayer', Published by David C. Cook, 2007.
The Bible tells us almost nothing about this mysterious day, sandwiched between the crucifixion and resurrection when God allowed the whole of creation to live without answers. Although we know so little about it, Holy Saturday describes the place where so many of us live our lives: waiting for God to speak. We know that Jesus died for us yesterday, we trust that there may be miracles tomorrow. But what of today, the no-man's land between questions and answers, when heaven is silent? It's not that God says 'yes', 'no' or 'not yet'; it's that he's not saying anything at all. Where, we wonder, is God now?
If we can't see God in our situation right now, we may feel scared, angry or helpless, or we may just want to give up altogether. But the Bible assures us that God has not left us, even if we can't feel his presence. Jesus promised to never leave us and the apostle Paul assures us that nothing can separate us from the love of God. The Bible leaves us in no doubt that when God is silent, he is not absent. Even if that's the way it feels. Instead, God has switched off for a while our ability to be conscious of his presence in order to reduce our dependency on outward things so that we learn some vital lesson of life that goes beyond purely rational understanding. If this is so, then the silence and unknowing of Holy Saturday are essential to growing deeper in our relationship with God. The silence of God is intentional. It is one of the great disciplines. Sometimes God removes the stabilisers from our bicycle and his hands from our frightened lives. As we grow towards spiritual maturity, every believer is granted seasons of unanswered prayer. At such times we may be sure that God is weaning us off 'adult supervision', but that he has not abandoned us altogether.
It is one of the great ironies of life that our unanswered prayers can be used to craft the greatest answers to prayer that we will ever experience. As long as it makes sense to serve God and to live for him, our faith can only mature so far. It isn't until the facts that reinforced our beliefs are removed from our lives that we can truly 'live by faith and not by sight'.
Nevertheless, these seasons can be deeply disturbing. As a result, we often attempt to solve the problem of God's silence with simplistic explanations of complex situations, lopsided applications of Scripture and platitudes of premature comfort. In our fear of un-knowing, we leap-frog Holy Saturday and rush the resurrection. When we experience similar seasons of doubt and despair, we too may be sure that resurrection is on the way. However, the experience of God's absence is not one to be rushed over as if it has no value in the Christian life. The basis of this is Christ's own experience of forsakenness on the cross, a moment that speaks profoundly about the meaning of God's silence. In the cross we see the hidden God who is with us in our suffering.
Even when God is silent, he is not absent.
In the rest of the book, Pete Grieg provides ways to move beyond mere endurance to active engagement with the unanswered prayers of our lives: engaging the silence.